TintMasters?

Tinted Windows, nascent supergroup.

Members:

• James Iha (underappreciated guitarist / songwriter) Smashing Pumpkins: +5
  
• The oblivious dude from Cheap Trick (drummer): +2
  
• Some guy from Fountains of Wayne (bass): +1
  
• One of the Hanson girls (vocals): -10

Sounds more like Fountains of Wayne than anything, but listening to this song gives me a queasy feeling in the pit of my stomach that in some alternate universe I could inadvertently be listening to something my nightmares tell me the Jonas Brothers sound like.

Worth it for the vintage Pumpkins mini-solo at 1:58, I tell myself.